We often wrestle with this question and I’ve
learned to accept it’s all the same (they are gone) but different. No matter how it was, we would always have to
balance the extra time we have with them with the suffering of a long illness.
We are all unique but alike, we just wear
different size shoes as we walk together. There are just so many different layers
to each circumstance. There are many horrific layers to seeing them suffer or
having them die without saying your final goodbyes.
I got the shock of my life in under an hour
with no goodbyes or a last I love you, but I didn't have to watch Donnie suffer
or watch him wither away. I grieve what we missed being able to do together. We
were supposed to retire and grow old together but it wasn’t meant to be.
I think the pain is the same no matter what,
but the time together and age when it happens and how fast it happens have
impacts on what kinds of challenges we will have. If you haven't had much time
together, you mourn the dreams that are lost. If you've had a lifetime
together, you mourn the memories you will no longer be making.
If you have young kids to raise that's a
different issue from being a grandparent (missing out on your "golden
years" together) or not having had kids at all (worrying about missing out
on the chance to ever have children). If it's fast, you are slammed with the
reality, but if it's long, you have the horrible memories of a decline and
perhaps difficulty adjusting to a life when you are no longer a caregiver.
I believe that grief is grief, loss is loss,
and while all of our stories are different the outcome is the same. We have
lost our parents, child, spouse, our loves, our friends and often suffer with the
feelings of abandonment, emptiness, anger, sadness, and the list goes on.
I also wrestled with this question when
Donnie died suddenly, but I have peace knowing that each possible scenario has
its good and bad sides and in searching, there is no easier scenario possible.
I could make a case for each situation, showing how they are worse, as well as
showing how they are better. I think, therefore, that it's not so much about
what's harder or what's easier as it is about what the different challenges
mean to you.
Truth is, each has their own set of
struggles. I don't think there is a "easier" way to lose someone you
love. In the end it comes down to what
my mother used to say to us, “it is what it is”.